My Best Cardiff City XI in Recent Years

As I’m only 20 years old I can’t say I’ve had the honour of seeing legendary City players such as Phil Dwyer, John Toshack and Fred Keenor play as they were well before my time. So I’ve decided to do my ‘modern’ greatest Cardiff 11, from when I went to my first game at Ninian Park, aged six.

Goalkeeper – Neil Alexander 

Appearances: 234

Goals: 0

Period at club: 28/05/2001 – 16/07/2007

We signed the original “Scotland’s number one” for £200,000 in 2001 and he spent six years at the club. He was a brilliant shot-stopper and I was always a big fan. Alexander was our keeper when we won the Division Two playoff final against QPR in 2003. Credit to both of our current goalies in Marshall and Heaton who I feel are two of the best we’ve had.

Left Back – Andy Legg 

Appearances: 209

Goals: 12

Period at club: 16/12/1998 – 21/07/2003

Leggy initially got stick from City fans when he joined us in 1998 as he previously played for Swansea. However, many solid and consistent performances (and an unbelievably long throw!) soon won over the Cardiff faithful as he became a fans favourite. Since his time at City, Legg has been diagnosed with cancer and has battled through it tremendously. I went to his testimonial match in 2006 which was a real treat as players from all generations were present.

Centre Back – Roger Johnson 

Appearances: 136

Goals: 14

Period at club: 04/07/2006 – 01/07/2009

Johnson was my favourite player during his time at the club, partly because I used to play in the centre of defence, and also because he was just awesome. Not only a rock at the back but he also contributed with a lot of goals going forward. Another shrewd Dave Jones signing as we got him for £275,000 and sold him for £5,000,000 three years later. For a Championship defender to be sold for that much just shows how good he really was. Ever present in our FA Cup Final campaign and scored a memorable diving header against then Premier League Middlesbrough.

Centre Back – Danny Gabbidon 

Appearances: 219

Goals: 10

Period at club: 10/08/2000 – 05/07/2005

Gabbidon’s excellent performances in a Cardiff shirt mean he has to be on my list. Another prominent member of the 2003 playoff winning side and I was gutted to see him leave alongside James Collins when the club was strapped for cash.

Right Back – Kevin McNaughton 

Appearances: 248 (At time of writing)

Goals: 2

Period at club: 26/05/2006 – Present

Super Kev is easily the best right back we’ve had in the last 15 years and has been a superb servant to Cardiff City. He covers so much ground in a game, up and down that right wing nonstop and was last season’s player of the year. He also has the best chant I think we’ve ever had for a player!

Left Midfield – Joe Ledley 

Appearances: 256

Goals: 30

Period at club: 01/09/2004 – 12/07/2010

I still have a shirt from quite a few years ago which had LEDLEY 16 on the back, and best of all I got it signed by the man himself! Chris Gunter egged him on to sign it ‘Deadly Ledley’ and to be honest I wish he had. Cardiff born and bred, Ledley scored some very important goals for the Bluebirds including the one against Barnsley to take us to the FA Cup final. Joe was also somewhat a utility player for City, playing all over midfield and also at left back. One of my favourite players and how I wish he was still on our wing!

Centre Midfield – Graham Kavanagh 

Appearances: 165

Goals: 31

Period at club: 29/06/2001 – 04/03/2005

An absolute legend as far as I’m concerned and my favourite ever Cardiff player. Kavanagh was the captain who led us to promotion in 2003 and always led by example. He set up god knows how many goals and also scored a few crackers in his time here too. Kav was City’s first £1 million man when he signed from Stoke in 2001, money that was unheard of before at Ninian Park. His most famous goal will be that free-kick when we beat the mighty Leeds in the FA Cup back in 2002. To say I was gutted when he was sold is an understatement, but I will always remember the magical moment when he scored the first ever goal at the CCS when he played in a one off ‘legends’ match.

Centre Midfield – Jason Koumas 

Appearances: 74

Goals: 15

Period at club: 27/07/2005 – 01/05/2006 and 04/08/2010 – 31/05/2011

With his first stint with us, Koumas was at the time the most skilful player I have ever seen don the blue shirt. I know he was only a loan signing but he was very influential in his time with us. He always looked dangerous on the ball and almost everything good we did that season came through him. A free-kick maestro, Koumas returned to us in 2010 but unfortunately was a shadow of his former self. However I remember the player that gave us many magic moments and that is why he’s on my list.

Right Midfield – Peter Whittingham 

Appearances: 257 (At time of writing)

Goals: 67

Period at club: 11/01/2007 – Present

Of course he’s on the list, “he does what he wants” after all! Easily our best player so far this season and always contributes with a lot of goals from midfield. Whitts always seems to have his own ‘goal of the season’ battle with himself and he truly has scored some screamers. The curling effort against Middlesbrough, the bullet free-kick versus Leicester, the keepy uppy and volley against Barnsley and the first time lob against Reading. All these are memorable goals and hopefully Whittingham will still be with us in years to come.

Striker – Robert Earnshaw 

Appearances: 220 (At time of writing)

Goals: 109

Period at club: 01/08/1997 – 30/08/2004 and 13/07/2011 – Present

Earnie is Cardiff’s second all time leading goal scorer and played a pivotal role in propelling us from Division 3 to Division 1, (now the Championship). He signed for us again this season but has barely featured so we haven’t seen that trademark summersault celebration as much as expected. Earnshaw holds the record for the most ever goals scored in a single season for us with 35 in the 2002/03 campaign. He was sold in 2004 for £3 million to West Brom and has always been a fans favourite at Cardiff.

Striker – Michael Chopra 

Appearances: 162

Goals: 65

Period at club: 16/06/2006 – 13/07/2007 and 06/11/2008 – 02/01/2009 and 02/02/2009 – 01/06/2009 and 04/07/2009 – 10/06/2011

One of the most prolific strikers in the Championship in recent years and has played for the Bluebirds on four occasions, twice on loan. We signed Chops for a mere £250,000 and he went on to be named player of the year in his first season with us. Chopra was sold for a club record £5 million to Premier League Sunderland in 2007 but we bought him back for another record fee of £4 million in 2009.

Total Caps of my Team: 2,180

Media from: http://www.cardiffcity-mad.co.uk, http://www.cardiffcityfc.co.uk, http://www.walesonline.co.uk
Advertisements

14 thoughts on “My Best Cardiff City XI in Recent Years

  1. Had exactly the same starting XI as you! Who would you put on your bench then? Let’s stick with current regulations and go with 5 on the bench..

    • Would you pick Loovens ahead of Johnson and Gabbidon? And I did think about Bellamy but I didn’t feel he deserved it.
      He signed with massive expectation, only played a few games for us due to injury and then left us following a season of disappointment. For me Whitts, Ledley and Kavanagh have to be on and for me Koumas did more for us than Bellamy.
      Whitts is on the right as I wanted to play 4-4-2 and had Ledley on the left 😛

  2. I think Loovens was better than Gabbidon for us. I think you’re very harsh on Bellamy though, he absolutely carried us at the end of last season and we wouldn’t have made the playoffs if it wasn’t for him. Whittingham has to be in the team I agree but I don’t think he has ever played on the right and it wouldn’t make sense to use him there! I’d go with Bellamy and Paul Parry on the wings. Kavanagh or Ledley and Whittingham in the middle.

    • I thought Bellamy was class at times just don’t feel he deserves to be in my best XI.
      And Whitts has played on the right a lot of times, especially in his early days with us.
      Good shout with Parry though, was always a big fan of his.

  3. I would make a few changes to yours and go with:

    Marshall

    Kev
    Loovens
    Gabbidon
    Legg

    Koumas
    Whitts
    Kav
    Bellamy

    Bothroyd
    Earnie

    • I think Ledley was a much better servant to Cardiff and more consistent than Bellamy. Bellamy made 35 appearances for City. Ledley made 256 and played in an FA Cup and Playoff Final for us, scoring the winner in the Cup semi final.

  4. Pingback: My Favourite Ever Cardiff City Match | A Bluebird's Eye View

  5. Pingback: My Top 20 Cardiff City Chants | A Bluebird's Eye View

  6. Pingback: Brighton 2 Cardiff City 2 | A Bluebird's Eye View

  7. Pingback: Crystal Palace 1 Cardiff City 2 Phew… | A Bluebird's Eye View

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s